The myth of connecting hardware power-sum performance claims

Sept. 1, 1998
Vendors who claim that their connecting hardware is "power-sum" compliant appear to offer a performance advantage over those vendors who specify their hardware`s worst-case pair-to-pair near- end crosstalk (NEXT) performance. Although perfectly applicable to the specification of cabling and cabling performance, some power-sum claims for connecting hardware are ill-founded and could result in end-users getting less than what they bargained for.

Valerie Rybinski

The Siemon Co.

Vendors who claim that their connecting hardware is "power-sum" compliant appear to offer a performance advantage over those vendors who specify their hardware`s worst-case pair-to-pair near- end crosstalk (NEXT) performance. Although perfectly applicable to the specification of cabling and cabling performance, some power-sum claims for connecting hardware are ill-founded and could result in end-users getting less than what they bargained for.

Historically, the rationale behind specifying power-sum near-end crosstalk (PS-NEXT) requirements for connecting hardware was based on the thinking that if power-sum channels are going to be specified, then power-sum components should be specified as well. Although there is some logic behind the statement, significant supporting data exists to demonstrate that a worst-case power-sum measurement is difficult, if not impossible, to apply consistently and accurately to connecting hardware qualification. To make matters worse, because a test algorithm for worst-case power-sum data collection does not exist, different manufacturers` power-sum claims may mean different things.

For example, a company can easily claim power-sum Category 5 performance for a connector based on data collected at one frequency point (such as 100 megahertz), measured in one test orientation (from the plug orientation only), with a high-end test plug rather than the full test-plug range specified in the TIA/EIA-568a Commercial Building Telecommunications Cabling Standard, or after testing in only one termination mode, such as the differential mode.

No basis in standards

A manufacturer must analyze hundreds of test configurations before reasonably claiming measured power-sum performance. Even then, there is no assurance that the worst-case test configuration has been evaluated. The PN-2948 Connecting Hardware Task Group of the Telecommunications Industry Association (Arlington, VA) recently addressed these concerns by specifying a worst-case pair-to-pair next characterization for connecting hardware that is sufficent to ensure channel and basic link ps-next performance. In fact, until such time as a power-sum test algorithm is defined, claims of "power-sum compliant" connecting hardware are not supported by industry standards.

The good news is that you can easily calculate an equivalent worst-case pair-to-pair next margin that correlates to Category 5 power-sum performance. By assessing the statistical relationship between pair-to-pair next values in connecting hardware, the tia PN-3727 utp Systems Task Group has determined that a common and differential mode pair-to-pair next margin of 3 decibels over Category 5 requirements is sufficient to ensure Category 5 power-sum performance.

In specifying connecting hardware, be sure to note worst-case guaranteed pair-to-pair next performance and verify that measurement margins are based on testing with and without common-mode terminations. Although power-sum claims may sound appealing, the power-sum algorithm tends to mask worst-case pair-to-pair performance for components that may prove cumulative--for example, two worst-case pair-to-pair combinations that are in a series and interact adversely in a channel configuration. Claims of connecting hardware power-sum performance are not sufficient to ensure proper channel near-end crosstalk performance.

Sponsored Recommendations

imVision® - Industry's Leading Automated Infrastructure Management (AIM) Solution

May 29, 2024
It's hard to manage what you can't see. Read more about how you can get visiability into your connected environment.

Adapt to higher fiber counts

May 29, 2024
Learn more on how new innovations help Data Centers adapt to higher fiber counts.

Going the Distance with Copper

May 29, 2024
CommScopes newest SYSTIMAX 2.0 copper solution is ready to run the distanceand then some.